When we rebuilt our own website, we moved to a static site. I wrote about why in why we rebuilt our website as a static site. But a static site isn’t right for everyone. Here’s how the three common options compare.
WordPress
WordPress powers a large share of the web. It’s a content management system: pages are stored in a database and built when visitors request them, with themes for design and plugins for features.
Strengths
- Very flexible, with plugins for nearly everything
- Easy for non-technical people to edit content
- Huge community and lots of developers
Weaknesses
- Needs regular updates to WordPress, the theme and plugins
- Plugins can conflict, slow the site or create security holes
- Heavy themes and page builders often load slowly on phones
- Hosting quality varies a lot
Best for: businesses that publish a lot of content themselves, or need specific plugins, and will keep it maintained.
Shopify
Shopify is a hosted platform built for online stores. You pay a monthly subscription, and Shopify handles hosting, security, checkout and payments.
Strengths
- Excellent for selling products online
- Secure checkout and payment handling built in
- Inventory, shipping and tax tools
- Large app store
Weaknesses
- Monthly fees and transaction or app costs add up
- Less flexible for content-heavy marketing pages
- Apps can slow the site
Best for: businesses that sell products online, especially with many items, shipping or local pickup. See our e-commerce page.
Static sites
A static site is built ahead of time into finished pages and served from a content delivery network close to the visitor. There’s no database generating pages on each visit.
Strengths
- Very fast on phones
- Very little to hack, since there’s no database or plugins exposed
- Little ongoing maintenance
- Inexpensive, reliable hosting
- Easy to build with clean code, schema and strong SEO foundations
Weaknesses
- Editing usually goes through your web team or a simple editor rather than a full content system
- Complex features, like logins or stores, need separate services
Best for: local service businesses whose website needs to be fast, rank well and turn visitors into calls. That’s most of our clients, which is why it’s our default. See web development.
Side by side
| WordPress | Shopify | Static site | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Speed | Varies, often slow | Good | Excellent |
| Security upkeep | Regular updates | Handled by Shopify | Minimal |
| Selling products | With plugins | Excellent | Needs a separate service |
| Self-editing | Easy | Easy for products | Through your team or simple editor |
| Ongoing costs | Hosting, plugins, upkeep | Subscription, apps, fees | Low hosting, care plan |
How to choose
Ask what your website really needs to do:
- Bring in calls and quote requests? A static site is usually the fastest, lowest-maintenance choice.
- Sell products online? Shopify, or a similar store platform.
- Publish lots of content yourself every week? WordPress, maintained properly.
Whatever you choose
- Own your domain, in your name
- Own your content and be able to export it
- Make sure redirects are handled if you change platforms
- Get Search Console and analytics set up from day one
Switching platforms is a good time to improve your site, but it’s also when rankings get lost if old URLs aren’t handled. Read my website redesign checklist before you move anything.
Questions to ask before you choose
- Who will update the site, and how often?
- Do you sell products online, or do you want calls and quote requests?
- Who will handle updates, backups and security?
- What will it cost each month once hosting, apps and plugins are added up?
- Can you take your content with you if you leave?