Before you start: why redesigns lose rankings
Your current website has history with Google. Some pages rank. Other sites link to specific URLs. Google has learned what each page is about. When a redesign changes those addresses or removes those pages without telling Google where things went, all that history points at dead ends.
The design almost never causes the drop. The migration does. So here’s the checklist.
Phase 1: Inventory
- List every URL on the current site. Crawl the site, export the sitemap, and pull pages from Search Console. Don’t forget old blog posts, PDFs and image URLs.
- Note which pages earn traffic. Search Console shows the pages and searches that bring clicks. These are your most valuable pages.
- Find pages other sites link to. Backlink tools show which URLs have links from other websites. Those links are worth protecting.
- Save the old content. Keep a copy of every page’s text, titles and descriptions, so nothing valuable gets lost in a rewrite.
- Record what you rank for today. A simple list of key searches and positions gives you a baseline to compare after launch.
Phase 2: Decide what each page becomes
Every old URL gets one of three decisions:
| Decision | When to use it | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Keep | The page ranks or converts | Same URL, improved content |
| Merge | Several thin pages cover one topic | Combine into one stronger page; redirect the others |
| Retire | Outdated or irrelevant | Redirect to the closest relevant page |
The rule I follow: nothing gets deleted without a redirect. A page that returns “not found” throws away whatever history it had.
When we rebuilt our own site, we kept every core service URL, merged dozens of thin city pages into stronger pages where search data showed real demand, and redirected the rest.
Phase 3: Build the new site the right way
- Keep page titles and topics close for pages that rank, then improve the content rather than replacing it with something unrelated.
- Make sure search engines can read the site. Content should be in the page’s HTML, not only assembled by scripts in the browser.
- Check the robots settings. Development sites are often blocked from search engines on purpose. That block has to come off at launch. It’s one of the most common, and most painful, launch mistakes.
- Add structured data and fresh titles and descriptions. A redesign is the cheapest moment to fix these. See technical SEO.
- Match your business details on every page to your Google Business Profile.
Phase 4: Launch day
- Put redirects live at the same moment as the new site. Not the next day.
- Test the redirects. Spot-check the old URLs on your list, especially the high-traffic ones and the ones with links.
- Copy over files people link to, like PDFs, your logo and any downloads, at the same addresses or with redirects.
- Submit the new sitemap in Search Console and request indexing for your most important pages.
- Test forms and phone links on a real phone. A beautiful new site with a broken contact form is a bad trade.
Phase 5: The weeks after
- Watch Search Console for “not found” errors and fix any missed redirects quickly.
- Compare rankings to your baseline. Small movements early on are normal. Big drops on specific pages usually point to a missing redirect or removed content.
- Check your leads. Calls and forms should hold steady or improve. If they drop, find out why before it becomes a habit.
- Keep the old content archive for a few months in case something needs to be restored.
Questions to ask your web designer
If you’re hiring someone for a redesign, ask them:
- How will you inventory our current URLs?
- Will we see the redirect map before launch?
- Who checks Search Console after launch, and for how long?
- What happens to pages that rank today?
- How will you make sure the site isn’t blocked from Google at launch?
A good designer will have clear answers. If they look puzzled, keep looking. This is the process our website redesign service follows for every Lubbock client.
— Chase