I hear this question a lot: “Should I do SEO or Google Ads?” The honest answer is that it depends on your situation, and for most Lubbock service businesses the answer ends up being “both, in the right proportions.” Here’s how I think about it.
How each works
PPC (pay-per-click) means you pay Google each time someone clicks your ad. Your ad shows at the top of results for searches you choose, as long as you’re paying and your ad wins the auction. Google Ads search campaigns, Local Services Ads and Performance Max all fall under paid search.
SEO (search engine optimization) means improving your website and online presence so you rank in the regular, unpaid results and in Google Maps. You don’t pay per click, but you invest time or money in content, technical work, your Google profile, reviews and links.
The quick comparison
| PPC | SEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Same day once approved | Usually months |
| Cost per click | You pay every click | No per-click cost |
| When you stop | Calls stop | Rankings fade slowly |
| Control | Exact searches, times and budget | Less direct control |
| Trust | Some people skip ads | Organic and map results are trusted |
| Best for | Urgent needs, seasonal spikes, testing | Long-term, lower cost per lead |
Renting vs. owning
I explain it like this: PPC is renting a spot on page one. It’s fast and flexible, and the moment you stop paying, you’re gone. SEO is building your own spot. It takes longer and needs maintenance, but once it’s built, it keeps producing without a per-click bill.
Don’t forget the map pack
For local service searches, Google Maps results often get more attention than the regular results. Ranking in the map pack comes from your Google Business Profile, reviews and website, not from ads. For many Lubbock businesses, this is the best return of all. See Google Maps optimization.
When I’d lean toward PPC
- You need calls this month
- Your work is urgent, like emergency repairs, where people call the first good option
- You have seasonal spikes, like hail season or the first heat wave
- You’re testing a new service or area and want data fast
- Your website is new and won’t rank for a while
When I’d lean toward SEO
- You can wait a few months for results
- Clicks in your industry are expensive
- You want a lower cost per lead over time
- You want to show up for research searches, like costs and comparisons
- You have a strong website or are willing to build one
Why most local businesses do both
The two work well together. Ads bring calls while SEO builds. Ad data shows which searches actually turn into jobs, which tells you which pages to build for SEO. And when you show up in both the ads and the organic results, you take up more of the page.
Over time, many businesses shift budget from ads toward SEO and Maps as organic results take over, keeping ads for urgent and seasonal demand.
The thing both need
Neither works if your website doesn’t convert. Sending paid clicks to a slow, confusing site wastes money fast, and ranking a weak page wastes the visibility you earned. That’s why I always look at the website first. Read the homepage conversion elements I check.
What one real account shows
On the West Texas contractor account our parent company CodeTap tracks, paid channels and organic both produced sold work, and the mix mattered more than any single channel. You can see the full breakdown by source.
How to decide
Start with your goals and timeline, your budget, and how urgent your customers’ needs are. Then make sure your tracking can show cost per sold job by channel, so you can shift money toward what works. Our budget calculator gives you a starting split. Or let us look at your market: our research and strategy work answers exactly this question before you spend.
I also wrote about running Google Ads in smaller markets like ours.