I can’t count how many owners have told me “most of my business is word of mouth” while also running Google Ads, a Google Business Profile and a website. Without tracking, everyone is guessing, and guesses usually favor whatever was most recent or most annoying.
Start with GA4
Google Analytics 4 is free and records visits and actions on your website. Out of the box, it tracks page views and some basic interactions. For a local business, the actions that matter are:
- Form submissions (quote requests, contact forms)
- Tap-to-call clicks on your phone number
- Online bookings
- Clicks to get directions, if customers come to you
Set these up as events, then mark the important ones as key events (what GA4 calls conversions). That’s what lets you see which traffic sources produce leads, not just visits.
Track tap-to-call clicks
On a phone, most people call by tapping your number. Every phone number on your site should be a tap-to-call link, and each tap should send an event to GA4. This tells you how many people tried to call from the website and which pages they came from.
It doesn’t tell you whether they actually connected, how long the call lasted or whether it was a real lead. That’s where call tracking comes in.
Add call tracking
Call tracking uses separate phone numbers for different sources so you can see which calls came from where. Common setups:
- Dynamic number insertion. Your website shows a different tracking number depending on how the visitor arrived: Google search, ads, social or direct. The calls all ring through to your real phone.
- Source-specific numbers. A number for your Google Ads call extensions, another for a mailer, another for a billboard.
Good call tracking records the source, the call length, whether it was answered and often a recording, so you can tell a real lead from a wrong number.
Protect your local SEO
Your main business number should stay consistent on your Google Business Profile, your website’s footer and your directory listings. Tracking numbers should be shown dynamically to website visitors, or added as an additional number on your profile, not swapped in everywhere. Done properly, call tracking doesn’t hurt local rankings.
Tag your campaign links
When you share a link in an email, a social post or an ad, add UTM parameters, tags at the end of the link that tell GA4 where the visit came from. For example, a link in your newsletter might include utm_source=newsletter and utm_medium=email. Google Ads can tag links automatically when linked to GA4.
Connect leads to sold jobs
This is the step most businesses skip, and it’s the one that answers the real question. GA4 can tell you a lead came from organic search. Your CRM tells you whether that lead became a $400 repair or a $15,000 replacement.
When each lead is recorded with its source, and each sold job is tied back to that lead, you can see revenue by channel. On one West Texas contractor account our parent company CodeTap tracks, that’s what showed which channels produced sold jobs and which only produced phone calls. You can see those real numbers here.
A simple setup checklist
| Item | Done? |
|---|---|
| GA4 installed on every page | |
| Form submissions tracked as key events | |
| Tap-to-call clicks tracked as key events | |
| Call tracking for website and ads | |
| Main number consistent on Google and directories | |
| UTM tags on email and social links | |
| Google Ads linked to GA4 | |
| Leads recorded with their source in a CRM | |
| Sold jobs tied back to leads |
What to look at each month
Keep it simple: leads by source, cost per lead for paid channels, and, once you have it, sold jobs and revenue by source. Use those numbers to decide where the next dollar goes. Our marketing ROI calculator helps you check a channel quickly.
If this sounds like a lot to set up, it’s a one-time job that pays for itself the first time it shows you a campaign that isn’t working. Our analytics and tracking service handles the full setup and the monthly reporting.