There’s a version of this article that ends with “so call us.” This isn’t it. The right answer depends on your time, your skills, your budget and how competitive your market is.
What you can realistically do yourself
Many important basics don’t require a marketing company:
- Claim and fill out your Google Business Profile. See how to claim it and how to optimize it.
- Ask every customer for a review and reply to every review. See my review strategy.
- Post real photos and updates weekly on your Google profile and social media.
- Fix your business details across major listings. See the citations guide.
- Answer every call and follow up on every lead quickly.
If you do just those things consistently, you’ll be ahead of many competitors. Our free local SEO checklist walks through them.
The real cost of DIY
DIY marketing isn’t free. It costs time, and owners usually have the least of it. Ask yourself:
- What is an hour of your time worth to your business?
- Will you keep doing it every week during your busy season?
- Do you enjoy it, or will it keep sliding to the bottom of the list?
Consistency is what makes local marketing work. If DIY means a burst of effort every few months, it won’t do much.
When an agency makes sense
- Technical work, like building a fast website, schema markup, redirects and tracking
- Competitive markets where you need deeper SEO and content work
- Paid ads, where mistakes waste money quickly
- Time, when your hours are better spent running the business
- Accountability, when you want reporting tied to calls and jobs
Red flags when hiring
I’ve cleaned up after enough bad arrangements to have a list:
- Long contracts with heavy cancellation terms
- The agency owns your website, domain or Google profile
- Guaranteed rankings, which no honest company can promise
- Reports full of vanity numbers but nothing about calls or jobs
- Nobody can explain what they actually did this month
- Ad spend mixed into the fee so you can’t see what Google charged
Questions to ask any agency
- Who owns the website, domain, content and Google profile?
- What’s the contract length and cancellation process?
- What exactly will you do each month?
- How will we track calls, leads and jobs?
- Who will I actually work with?
- Can I see work for businesses like mine?
We publish our answers on our pricing and about pages, because owners deserve to know before they call.
The hybrid approach
Many of our clients split the work. They handle reviews, photos and answering the phone. We handle the website, technical SEO, Google profile optimization, ads and tracking. That plays to everyone’s strengths and keeps costs reasonable.
How to decide
List what needs doing, mark what you can do consistently, and look at what’s left. If what’s left is small, keep doing it yourself. If it’s big, technical or keeps not getting done, that’s where help pays for itself. If you’re unsure, our research and strategy work gives you a plan you can carry out yourself or hand to us.
What we’d tell you not to pay for
Being honest cuts both ways. If you’re paying anyone for a monthly report that nobody reads, a social media package that posts stock images, or an SEO plan with no pages being built or improved, you’re probably paying for activity rather than results. Ask what changed on your website and Google profile each month. If nobody can answer, that money is better spent elsewhere, or kept.